Menu of Beal's Old Fashioned Ice Cream in Portland, Maine, USA

Menu Overview

Beal's Old Fashioned Ice Cream, nestled in the heart of Portland, ME, offers a nostalgic journey through rich, handcrafted flavors that beautifully balance tradition with inventive flair. Situated at 12 Moulton St, this charming ice cream shop delights with a diverse menu that caters to all palates, from classic favorites like Vanilla Ice Cream and Hot Fudge to more adventurous choices such as Teaberry Ice Cream and Blueberry Cobbler.

The standout items reflect Beal's commitment to quality and creativity. The Blueberry Cobbler is a luscious treat that marries the comforting warmth of homemade cobbler with the cool, creamy texture of ice cream. This flavor perfectly showcases the shop’s knack for combining familiar desserts into refreshing frozen masterpieces. Similarly, the Heath Bar and Moose Tracks options deliver layers of crunchy, sweet, and chocolatey satisfaction, making every bite indulgent.

What truly sets Beal's apart is not just the quality but the variety and thoughtful curation. From the subtle floral notes of the Teaberry Ice Cream to the rich decadence of the Brownie Sunday—featuring Moose Tracks and Chocolate Ice Cream—the menu invites exploration and offers a bespoke ice cream experience. The Italian Ice and Salted Caramel Cookie flavors further illustrate how the shop blends classic and contemporary tastes in harmony.

Customers praise the shop's friendly staff and the welcoming, artsy ambiance of the location, which adds to the charm of visiting. The homemade waffle cones elevate the experience, adding texture and warmth that contrasts perfectly with the cool, creamy scoops. Although seating is limited, the intimate setting encourages patrons to savor their ice cream mindfully, a testament to the shop’s artisanal approach.

Whether indulging in a single scoop served in a waffle cone or sampling a 4 x 2 scoop flight to savor a medley of tastes like blueberry, coffee, black raspberry, and red raspberry swirl, Beal's delivers consistently excellent, creamy ice cream with a well-rounded flavor profile. The inclusion of dairy-free options and inventive flavors like Orange Pineapple and Almond Butter Crunch broadens its appeal, ensuring everyone finds something delightful.

In summary, Beal's Old Fashioned Ice Cream is a must-visit for ice cream enthusiasts seeking both nostalgia and novelty. The menu shines through its rich selection, artisanal flavors, and an inviting atmosphere that make every visit memorable. With quality ingredients, whimsical flavor combinations, and attentive service, Beal's elevates the simple joy of ice cream into a heartfelt experience.